Showing posts with label 2015 Agbogbloshie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2015 Agbogbloshie. Show all posts

Shame Blowback: Jim Puckett's 2015 Claim to be an Authority on Agbogbloshie

"The #TechSector in #EmergingMarkets honestly believes in the #CircularEconomy. But like Copernicus and Galileo, they do not believe it revolves around you." - Robin Freeland Ingenthron

That's my favorite self-quote from the past 10 years. I got to deliver it to a European Conference on E-Waste, seated side by side with Basel Action Network's executive director, Jim Puckett. 

"Shame Blowback" sometimes takes years. But Karma Occurs. 

After the laughter subsided, I told the audience that it is a bit absurd that they are relying on the advice of two white American men to explain the situation with used electronics in Africa's Tech Sector. Adam Minter later told me that #OwnVoices was a hashtag which framed that dynamic. The following year, Emmanuel Nyaletey was invited to present to the same conference audience. 

2007 Film Falsely Claimed these were illegally dumped. Lie,


Quickie documentary videos of Africa-bound sea containers shocked Europeans into twisting the Basel Convention - which explicitly identifies intent to dump, not intent to recycle or repair, as illegal - to a snare for African and Asian and Latin Americans in the reuse sector. Joe Benson was entrapped in that snare, which was baited by Jim Puckett with false claims, delivered in less than flowering Halloweenish descriptions of African Cities ("A Place Called Away"), that 80% of the trade Africans engage in is a "sham". "Millions of tons" "pawed through" by "orphans" in "the largest e-waste dump in the world".

Review: Jacopo Ottaviani Documentary "E-waste Republic" Mystery Vault

The great news is that  -- compared to previous articles (via BBC, The Atlantic, The Guardian, NPR,  NY Times, Washington Post, Wired, etc.) -- the web documentary appearing yesterday on Al Jazeera and internazionale by young Italian reporters Jacopo Ottaviani and Isacco Chiaf, "E-waste Republic"*, is much more sophisticated.  It allows many other (English-speaking) voices to come forward and describe the nuance of a scrap problem in an African city.

* edited redirect to Der Spiegel 2022.09.27

This documentary is far ahead of the pack in documenting the complex pieces of the electronic reuse and scrap markets in Africa.   And they hit the nail on the head by stating that demolishing Agbogbloshie will make the problem worse.

Kudos to Ottaviani for interviewing second hand dealers and repair shops, and giving time to yours truly (on behalf of WR3A / Fair Trade Recycling).  They give author Adam Minter [whose own accounts of Agbogbloshie are frankly more factual] almost as much screen time as Mike Anane.  There are data and statistics, and the documentary stands apart from the lie that boycotting Africa's Geeks will somehow make wire burning juveniles "go away".  I thank and respect Ottaviani and Chiaf for taking the hours and hours to get a "whole story" perspective.

What the documentary fails to do, sadly, is to correct the proportion distortion. or the myth that import for repair is "illegal".  Like Kyle Wiens piece @Wired, Ottaviani recognizes the demolition of the slum is bad - but alsocontinues to make the story about westerners' stuff.  This continues the central conceit that Agbogbloshie's problems somehow revolve significantly around "imported e-waste".

The focus on e-waste exports in sea containers is the Mystery of Al Capone's vault, 29 years after.



[ postscript:  This was a tricky blog to write, as I respect Jacopo and Isacco and value the effort to interview #geeksofcolor and tell a nuanced account.  But it also perpetuates definitions of #ewaste that include reuse and repair, and false testimony about volumes and timelines of simply disposed waste, and honestly it does represent another example of photojournalism's need for exotic hooks. ]

"Here to Help" Part 1: Is GAHP a Charitable Industrial Complex Honeypot?

#dennismoorecrime #environmentalmalpractice #parasitesofthepoor #whitesaviorcomplex #whiteguilt #morallicense #charitableindustrialcomplex #heretohelp
[Any photos or screen shots from the following sites below are claimed under the "fair use" exception, they are specific evidence in a commentary, policy critique, and use of public and charitable tax exempt funds]

Demonstration of $75K portion of $1.2M investment:  Turning 1kg of wire worth $0.70 into 0.7 kg of wire worth $1.00 

From the outset, let's acknowledge the do-gooders mean well.  They are here to help.  If they turned out to be what one Africa directed blogger coined as #parasitesofthepoor, or arrested one of Africa's best and brightest Tech Sector employers, it's a "Dennis Moore crime".  Redistribution of recycling was trickier than they thought.

"Ewaste Crimes in Ghana": Intermission

End of Week 2 in Africa.

To catch everyone up, here are the cliff notes.

1) In 2002 three Americans were in Guangdong... Jim Puckett (BAN), Adam Minter (Shanghaiscrap.com), and yours truly.   We saw different things.   But the report with the least nuance (BAN's 80% dumping claim, claim that the water pollution was from e-Waste etc) got the biggest headline.  

Make the biggest claim, get the biggest coverage.

Where there's smoke, there's Tires.  Most of the visible smoke s from the tires.



2)  In fact Guiyu China was not receiving the CRT monitors, they were going to SKD semiknockdown factories for remanufacture, and the water pollution found in "Exporting Harm" was telltale from textile dying.    However, BAN ignored the nuance and created a Pledge of True Stewardship to raise more funds for their fledgling NGO.

2015 "Ewaste Crimes" in Ghana: Day 2

In 1985, when I lived in Cameroon, and visited a large city like Yaounde or Douala, crossing the street was not too difficult.   As you stood at the corner and watched vehicles go by, it looked something like this...
Taxi.  Taxi.  Taxi.  Truck.  TaxiVan. Taxi. Taxi. Mercedes.  TaxiVan. Taxi. Truck...
Here in Accra, capital of Ghana, thirty years later, things have changed.
Taxi. Toyota.  Honda. Truck.  Taxi.  Mercedes.  Infiniti. TaxiVan.  Truck.  Taxi. Truck. Jaguar.  Truck, Hyundai, Taxi, GMC, Taxi, Taxivan, Truck, Nissan, Toyota.... and the sentence goes on and on for half a page.
We were on our way to the "scene of the crime".  The place Blacksmith Institute placed at the top of their list of most toxic places on the planet.  Where Frontline interviewed Jim Puckett, describing the place where "most" of the world's e-waste goes.  Where Mr. Mike Anane says 500 sea containers per month arrive for primitive dumping.  Where several sources describe, and I quote, "Millions of tons of e-waste per year" are dumped and burned.  The site described by Joe Benson's prosecutor as "common knowledge" that 80 percent (that #$%$ stat) winds up after Benson exported it.


I will have to upload some of the photos later.

Millions of tons (I actually had to edit that claim out of Wikipedia and identify the source had misquoted a study saying that was the world's generation, and then applied 80% literally to Agbogbloshie). That's 60 to 90 million CRTs, if it's at least 2 million tons.

(I took about 150 photos, but most of my photos were of the photographers... I'll talk about why.  The shots are too big to upload here from my Ghana pocket wifi Vodaphone transceiver.  Some from Fair Trade Recycling e-waste reform Facebook Page).



There were about 50 people, including myself and an American and two European reporters and my friends  who took us there - my Ghana Geek pal Wahab, two of his cousins (all from same tribe and locale as the teenagers at the dump) and a lawyer and import agent.  About 25 of them were "on the job".

2015 "E-Waste Crimes" in Ghana: Day 1

I'm in Africa.  I see junk TVs here.  I also see junk cars and tires.  And traffic jams.  Tomorrow, I will go to Agbogbloshie, to make my pilgrimmage as an exotic photographer.  But before I go there, I thought I'd refresh myself on the history of television in Africa.  I'm still concerned with what I call "The Banana Peel Fallacy", which I described in 2009's blog "Monkeys Running the Environmental Zoo".


Activist goes to the zoo and finds the floor of the monkey cages covered with banana peels.  He takes pictures of the peels.  But it is a fallacy to accuse the zookeeper or visitors of dumping their banana peels in the monkey cage.  There is no evidence of "banana peel dumping".

As I said in the Zoo blog, I do not equate Africans with monkeys, but it describes both the fallacy of thinking you know what happened and a third party assigning victimhood to the consumer.  In the analogy, the protester jumps to a conclusion.  It's that protester who is seeing the emerging world as helpless zoo animals.

Most African cities had television in the 1970s.  But like televisions in the USA in the 1940s, they were a luxury device which could never have been afforded by the average African.  In the 1970s, Americans and Europeans read about Africa through the lens of Idi Amin and Mobutu Seko Sede, Apartheid regimes in South Africa.   Barely a decade earlier, most of Africa was still ruled by colonial law.

Mass Media in Sub-Saharan Africa

 By Louise M. Bourgaul (1995)
Technically, many capital cities in Africa had television stations in 1959 or 1960, at independence, but tended to be "an elite an urban phenomenon" (Borugaul), and stayed that way until the advent of the Videotape Recorder / VCR.  The VCR meant that any better-off African, not just those in the capital, could brag about their TVs.

Zaire Television concern, Kinshasa, 1970s
In the 1980s, black and white television was a forgotten technology in the USA and Europe, but some Africans benefitted by purchasing the used black and white televisions.   But since it was an elite thing, most could opt for a used color TV instead.

While broadcast stations and programming were limited, the VCRs and cassette tapes were ubiquitous.  To the consternation of Hollywood, Nigerian VHS copies of movies became a world industry.  Few African households could have afforded legitimate versions, but in a way Nigerian "copyright pirates" were helping Hollywood, by bringing their music videos and movies to audiences who otherwise would have grown up with Bollywood posters.   I watched Sly Stallone's Rocky and Rambo, and Phil Collins videos (too many times) on a visit to a village south of Bamenda in 1985.  My friends say around, commenting on Phil Collins' lyrics.  "It would appear he does not care anymore.  No, surely, this man does not care."

Even my remote town in north central Cameroon had a few households with television before I left in 86.  We had no post office, no bank, no hospital, and were blessed with a single paved road.  The school I taught at was itself less than 4 years old.  It was called a "pioneer post" by the Peace Corps staff, one of the most rural, a start-up program.  But before I left in 1986, my landlord across the yard had a color television.   It was used 1970s model, imported from England.