Legal Dual Party Intent, Part II E-waste

A flow diagram has been circulated by the Basel Action Network which shows how illgal waste can move across international boundaries.  That organization's concern over waste cost "externalization" is genuine.  Hopefully, they will consider the advice of a fellow environmentalist with open minds.

In the "decision tree procedure" shared by BAN, a question posed under "Refurbishment/Repair" is:


Will the computing equipment be repaired, refur­bished or upgraded in the importing country?

To sell overseas, you need wholesale shipments.   It's extremely difficult to know whether the end user, a buyer (such as the owner of an internet cafe) will replace an English keyboard, or upgrade a stick of RAM.  The question is whether that person's decision, dictating the outcome of the part, is "generation" (the waste is generated in the buyer's country of possession) or whether the original USA exporter is the generator.

It's not just the disposal of small upgraded parts like capacitors, keyboards, and RAM sticks that make "elective generation" a challenging question.  If I live in Singapore, and I buy a used PC, and I decide to throw the whole thing away, who is the generator? What if human error occurs at retail store in Bangladesh?  Was the "e-waste" generated in Bangladesh, or by the person who originally owned the monitor?  If the latter, perhaps "no intact unit" is indeed the logical outcome of strictest Basel interpretations.

WR3A believes that communication, standards, and reconciliation of accidents/misunderstandings will lead to the best outcomes.  By last summer, WR3A had sold over 300,000 computer monitors.  Because we communicate and share data with our end market, we have a good idea what happened to each one, why it happened, and to reduce the incidents of unintended outcomes in the future.  We are "exporters" with consciences, repairmen without borders.

The test in italics above demands that a supplier predict the future.  In the previous post, I showed how the recommended "tested working" and "fully functional" labels can also produce waste.  If their argument is that "if waste occurs, the transaction is illegal", it is an absolute interpretation of the Basel Convention, and any of the following can also be "illegal".  If the resulting "e-waste" generation is not attached to the elective action of the buyer (e.g. to upgrade the device, could be considered "generation" after receipt), but to the country of origin of the material, the following would also be considered "movement" of material "generated" in the USA, Japan, Korea or EU:
  • Sale of brand new product.  BAN has argued that a non-working part which is present in the importing country can be traced back to the shipper, and constitutes illegal movement of waste.  Even if the replaced part is not discarded, having been shipped it has already a violation of the convention.  Therefore, brand new computers sold to an emerging markete under warranty will also have violated laws if the goods are indeed returned under warranty.   Returns of televisions and computers to Wal-Mart are approximately 10%;  if it's a similar return rate overseas, then it is worse than many shipments of screen electronics for repair.  And remember, any sale - of cell phones, of laptops, of satellite dishes - will someday become either a waste or an antique, and antiques only have value when they are rare.
  • Sale of tested working product with elective upgrade.  If you sell a tested working computer to a knowlegable party, they are likely to replace RAM, hard drives, power supplies and other components which work but can be improved on.   In the BAN flow diagram, those electively removed parts would fail the transboundary test in the same way as parts from refurbishing.  In fact, the SKD factories (a process BAN objects to) is itself an elective upgrade - those big secret factories buy tested working monitors, and they also electively choose not to SKD refurbish non-working monitors, selling them for direct reuse, according to monthly supply and demand.

Legal Dual Party Intent

When two parties to a reuse trade both agree on specifications, both agree on terms of delivery, etc., then the next step is to ensure the trade is profitable and legal.

The profitability of the transaction is best left to the parties of the trade.  There's no profit police.

The question in the e-waste trade is legality.  If the trade is transparent, then you can assume that the intent is to be legal.  However, transparency is not always profitable - competitors see what you are doing, and it can affect your head start and your markets.

Sea containers and "shippable quantities" and time constraints can lead to some unintended riders on the transaction, contaminants, etc.   If something is truly e-waste, i.e. discarded, then there would have to be significant avoided disposal cost for the two parties to agree to trans-ship large quantities of the material profitably.   Radioactive and chemical waste have that potential.

For used electronics, the avoided disposal costs are between 10 cents and 40 cents per pound.  The more reuse income is restricted, the higher the disposal costs.  (The northeastern USA rates are approximately half the rates in California, largely due to the SB20 "cancellation rule").

So how does "e-waste" get where it isn't wanted?  The simplistic notion is "high avoided disposal costs (externalization), poor enforcement".  The remedies proposed are more enforcement, reform or externalized markets, or lower internal costs.

What really clouds the discussion is the inclusion of de minimus quantities of unintended and negligible quantities of goods... like the two little capacitors replaced in the repair of a Dell Optiplex.  It distracts limited enforcement, undermines the most capable people who can reform recycling in external markets, and it increases internal costs. 

Slums and Recycling and Environmental Justice

I ended last weekend's post with the observation that rich markets don't nurture the skill to repair devices.  We can buy new and be happy.  Unfortunately, environmental stewards are designing export rules and systems based on what we (the wealthy) are willing to do, not what they, the Techs of Color, are ABLE to do..

Last Sunday I was re-watching Slumdog Millionaire, telling my kids about the societies that grow around dumps.  Like the Egyptian Zabaleen, the lower castes in Philippines, the Indian tribes in Brazil profiled in last month's New York Times, the repairmen of Bangalore, or the "slumdogs" of Mumbai... Whenever I see them, these illiterate, often orphaned, primary school drop outs, I think of the opposite. 

I remember the best and smartest students in my classrooms in Cameroon, Africa, reading "Technical Textbooks" in "technique" classes.  Beefing up on schematic diagrams, electricity, currents, and physics in a classroom without even a light switch.  It was the most stubbornly smart students, earning "As", that I thought about most when I left my post.  Where would they find jobs which would reward that creativity, knowledge and patience?

It is, in my view, God's plan that the smartest kids fix and repair and salvage value from the richest kids.  It's a far better vision than the rich kids donating working equipment to the poor kids.  You actually want the smart kids from the classroom in Cameroon to be the ones that next generations emulate, who succeed more than "functionnaire" classes, law enforcement, or criminals.  This is the way South Korea, Singapore, Japan and other nations went from backwards to emerging to developed nations in record time.

Better or worse, Americans and Europeans have some intense and conflicted emotions when it comes to the relationship between recycling and slums and "environmental justice".

Here is a story from a few years ago about the electronics repair culture in Egypt.  The same disdain the Indian authorities have for the boy in "Slumdog Millionaire" can be seen in all these other cultures where very large urban areas create a waste stream which scavenger cultures can earn a living in recycling.

I don't disdain people who work hard recycling.  I am able to control the "shame and guilt" reflex, which also serves me well among Vermont deer hunters, Arkansas chicken farmers, and people in wheelchairs.  The idea is that you don't let your own subjective paranoia irritate the life of the people you meet.  Dudes, we'll all be dead in a few decades, let's get along and trade and do neat shit together.

My first time in China, I stood at the back dock of the hotel in Guangzhou, looking at a 4 cy dumpster.  I watched as a small packer garbage truck with 5 uniformed men backed up to the dumpster - three were in the cab, two rode standing on the sides of the truck.  They were met by 7 uniformed hotel staff.  Together these 12 men rolled out a 30 square meter tarp, and tipped the dumpster over by hand.  They sorted out all the garbage by paper, glass, metals, food... and arranged them in sedimentary layers for the garbage packer.  I guess when it unloaded (which I visited later that night) they would find it easier to sort again.

So, I know both something about the extreme conditions people in these countries live in, and given those conditions, how easy it is to exploit their poverty and their need.  I also know their intelligence, their ability, and the importance of retained and added value in their income. Fair trade and reform is delicate surgery on the free market, and good intentions are not enough.



"Without mandatory testing and controls, re-use can be pretext (intentionally or not) for exporting junk."

So true, dudes.  WR3A strongly agrees with BAN on this statement.  We differ on what the "tests" are, in some cases, but will accept numbers and data about which method got the most good stuff for the least environmental cost.  I mean, we KNOW mining and refining and manufacture and disposal..  We got that beat with our recycling eyes closed.  But whether the WR3A audited-end-market or the BAN audited-shipper works best, let's look at some control groups and some numbers and figure this out. But where BAN and PACE went astray was in failing to include the importers, the "Tech Sector", in defining those tests.  The best and brightest should be writing their own purchase orders.

We know that WITH mandatory testing and controls, re-use can be pretext for exporting junk, as demonstrated in the previous blog.  Or the exporters just declare it all "tested working".   Or the recyclers shred it and don't bother testing something that "might" fail.

"Export for repair can involve export for disposal."

Well, yeah.   Export of brand new product can involve export for disposal.  Sending a gift by mail can involve export for disposal.   WR3A agrees with this statement, that repair can or might involve export for disposal.  Like, Halloween candy might be poisoned.   If the cases of poisoning get very high, I'll stop accepting any candy and bob for Vermont apples in my house.

Sometimes imports don't work out, new, tested working, or not.  Brand new devices are returned about 10% of the time in the USA.  WR3A has sought to establish progressive policies encouraging or requiring recycling of the parts that are replaced.   This is commonly required already at contract manufacturing factories which assemble and test new products (some fail or are damaged in assembly, and are recycled), and required of these factories when computers and monitors are sent back for warranty repairs.   As posted in the "Capacitor Wars" blog, the parts BAN objects to can be extremely small and non-toxic.  Some repairs, such as degaussing and bypass, require no replaced parts whatsoever.   Therefore, the conclusion that "fully functional" is the definition meant by Basel Convention's language "repair and refurbishing" (allowed) is an overreaction of dramatic proportions.


"Exporting toxic for re-use to poorer consumers constitutes "passing the buck" and environmental injustice."

Unlike the statements above, BAN does not qualify this statement with "can", "may", or "might".  "Loves watermelon and fried chicken" might be a true statement.   But if BAN states that this is the outcome in all cases, they are prejudiced.  Retroworks de Mexico offers $5 off of any working TV (re)sold if the Mexican consumer brings in a junk one, in our "coupon for clunkers" program.  Our partner in Asia started out recycling incidental breakage for WR3A (which the shipper pays for), and they are now collecting from in-country in pretty large quantities.  ITIC -  I Think It's Cool!

If I export a used electric guitar to my friends Fela, Franco, and Aurlus Mabele, and they replace the amperage to meet 220v current, replacing the 110v switch, and I take the old power switch back in the USA and dispose of it safely - according to BAN's schematic, I have committed an environmental crime.  It's too mad that these soukous musicians know way more about electric guitars than I do.  I need to hire a white American soukous guitar expert here in the USA to make sure the guitar is tuned. 


"Exporting toxic equipment for reuse to poorer consumers equates to 'passing the buck' and environmental injustice."

"Equates"?  I think brand new ones also eventually "equate" to needing repairs, which may equate to a part being replaced or upgraded, which will equate to recycling.   Ok.  So I stay barefoot and pregnant until you get around to LEASING me a brand new computer?

Locating an itty bitty capacitor which was replaced, or a 128k RAM stick that was upgraded, and pointing to it as the "outcome" of trade is such a hyperbolic description of fair trade that it makes me crazy.

If an Egyptian hospital intern buys a brand new $800 PC on his $3k per year salary, is that a better outcome than if he can get online with a $80 PC? "Let them eat cake"? The solution is 1) get the student online, and 2) get him a recycling infrastructure.  In that order, dude.  Like USA and the developed countries did.


"Repair and recycling are very likely to INVOLVE a recycling or disposal destinations"

Any form of ownership, of tested working or brand new, eventually "involves" recycling and disposal.  Here,  "recycling or disposal" are grouped in the sentence as if these are morally and environmentally the same outcome.  So whether a Lagos doctor recycles or disposes of his computer, it is the same?  When I recycle rather than dispose, I am a good person.  Whether the person in the developing world recycles or disposes is NOT the same outcome.  Recycling is NOT disposal.  And this brings us back to the Slumdog Millionaires, the informal scrap sector we opened with.  While they are not as educated as the Tech Sector which arranges to purchase and import used electronics, they are not shameful or "primitive".  I've said many times, white boy scouts and girl scouts earn medals for recycling, it beats the heck out of mining jobs in Africa, or worse places orphans and drop-outs could wind up.

Fair trade advocates, like WR3A members, care which outcome, repair or recycling or disposal, is going to happen.  It matters a lot.  I look forward to the receipt reports and reconciliations of the 300,000 Steward "tested working" units, to compare them with the outcome of the 300,000 units WR3A has managed export of during the past 3 years. Saying a "black person" or "Asian" winds up with the second hand goods is not an "outcome".

The entire debate begs the questions:  Can poor people recycle?

This is surreal.  Good God!  If recycling is disposal, and a part removed during repair is recycled, therefore repair is equal to disposal?  The only possible explanation for BAN's insistence on this standard is financial.  Start watching the organizations IRS Form 990, there is something fishy going on here, and it probably involves Planned Obsolescence or Big Shred.

Going back to the introduction of this post, I've been promoting recycling since high school in the 1970s.   I studied international relations, and went into Peace Corps in the 1980s.  The very best outcome God and the Free Market provide, to reward the best and brightest geeks in the poorest countries, is at risk if reuse equals disposal, and the explicit right-to-repair clauses of the Basel Convention are forgotten.


Compromise is overdue.  Our e-waste recycling industry has a mandate to address the environmental concerns which have been raised.   There is more at stake than pollution or affordable electronics recycling.  When good things happen naturally in a free market, it is vital that whatever market corrections we need to implement do not hamper or retard the Good.

It is time to find middle ground between the Perfect and the Good.

[edited 2018.01.14 for clarity and spelling]

Laptop battery secret

Laptop batteries are made with extreme violence to the earth, extraction of rare earths, disturbance of fauna.  I use a laptop and I like it.   Here's something I learned at the ICRS Summit.

If you leave your laptop plugged in when it's fully charged, you are keeping its battery in an unnatural state.  It's actually designed to try to discharge itself as you are charging it.  The heat of being fully charged is tough on the battery.  If you like ordering $30-50 replacement batteries, plus shipping, I guess it's no big deal for you, but the environment would appreciate you taking the following step.

The best solution is the remove or kick-out the battery if you are sitting down and leaving it plugged in for awhile.  You can extend the battery life by a few years if you make that a habit.  Of course, you want to save your work more often.  And don't kick the cord out of the wall like I do.

Thanks to Paul Bessey of BatteriesPlus (Addison, Illinois) for this helpful hint towards source reduction of "e-waste".

"Whatever Happened to WR3A?"

When we incorporated the World Reuse, Repair and Recycling Association (WR3A.org) in 2006, we had visions of managing all the good material from all the good companies, and using the cooperative tonnage to supply good tonnage, below cost, to flush out the sleazy exporters, who we found the export market doesn't really like very well to begin with.  We got great response to the "Fair Trade" concept, from EPA, BAN Pledge companies, companies who were rethinking their shredder purchases,  and especially from buyers overseas.

After 3 years of attempting to broker display devices, I can report what has worked and what has failed. 

Fair Trade Recycling as a message has been enormously successful - primarily overseas, and among people who know the markets overseas.  The choices of "all or nothing" are still stupid and anti-productive.  We have members who don't trade through us at all, but want to support Fair Trade.

WR3A does speed the process.   Established members take risks on new buyers, and once we've visited, they've visited, we've audited each other, etc., we can move on and shift another vendor's material to the market we are confident in, and move on to develop a new market.  I can use my own loads as "blind shipments" so that we know what's likely the truth in the event of an argument. Buyers and sellers both appreciate getting away from the "fly and buy" inspection process, inspecting every load, and pooling auditing resources.  It's not perfect, but I've found it enormously rewarding.

However, the orginal vision for WR3A as a massive coop was just too difficult, given the fluctuations of CRT values.   Members were "jumping in and out" of purchase orders, shipping through WR3A when prices were down, cutting WR3A buyers off when prices were up.   Not evil, but the outcome was that I became more of an agent for the buyers than a representative of the sellers.


There were several cases when an overseas factory had tremendous potential, but we didn't have a fit between supplies and demand.  Three factories I visited had credentials as original equipment manufacturers for huge OEMs.  One had glass-to-glass recycling of bad units, an import permit, and ISO14001 and 9000... but they needed 100,000 CRTs per month.  WR3A wanted them to stop buying from exporters who our members thought were shipping TAR.   The factory said they needed 100k units.   If we supplied them, they'd rely on  WR3A.  But if WR3A only had 50k and were selling 35k of those to a different factory, they didn't have time for it.

There is also the adage, "don't be a crane among the chickens".   Some factories do good work but don't want any publicity.

As the market shrinks, WR3A finds it easier and easier to meet entire factory purchase orders.  Unfortunately, at the same time, WR3A lost suppliers.  The most common reason cited when a supplier adapts "no intact unit" policies is that they are afraid of being accused as an exporter.  The second is that they prefer private, quiet transactions, and don't see the value of a high profile relationship with WR3A.  Then there are some who are shocked and embarrassed to see their reconciliation reports... they thought their staff was testing everything, but have never seen an actual report back from the buyer.

The most common reason people try to join WR3A is that they already export whatever they want, and they like the message "Exports Good!"  Which isn't exactly what we are looking for.


So why join WR3A?
  • To support responsible recycling practices.
  • To speed tramsactions
  • To obtain the best possible reports of actual reuse (per Federal CRT Rule).
  • To get invited to cool operations overseas.
  • To provide talented
  • To pre-vet your operation using desk audits (CRT Glass test, PCB test, etc.)
  • Free consulting expertise
In a future post, we'll go behind the scenes, and document both SSFFs*

(Started, Sprinted, Finished First)
(Started, Stumbled, Farted, Fell)