"E-Waste" Is Never Reused

In 100 percent of cases, we do know this.  "E-waste cannot ever be reused for its intended purpose." 

How am I so sure?  Because if it is reused, then it was not "e-waste" to begin with!  Waste is by definition discarded, disposed material.  The problem is to ensure real reuse, so that junk isn't sent as "toxics along for the ride".  WR3A's approach is to warranty our exports.

This requires ongoing dialogue with the buyer, not for one party to perform tests and then ship blindly. We don't say "we met someone's definition of working, now it's your problem".  In fact, the highest warranty claims on WR3A monitors were for working items that the buyer couldn't digest because we shipped more than they were prepared to handle, and they had to rent additional warehouse space until we cut off suppliers.  The suppliers we cut off?  No mystery, the ones with the worst reconciliation reports.  The free market is like "Survivor", the buyers keep the relationships that consistently deliver the highest quality.

The decision tree WR3A uses is a demand-centered diagram.  It does allow repair in non-OECD countries, but produces fewer discards.  It refuses tested working product which is in excess of capacity, or which has no more market.   It recognizes the incidental breakage and parts replacements, like those BAN's decision tree cannot stop (hemisphere, voltage, elective upgrades), but requires documentation of proper recycling of those incidentals.  In so doing, we are creating a recycling infrastructure in the developing nations, which are the largest source of discarded "e-waste" in their own countries.

Importers do not pay 10 dollars for a piece of equipment which has only 1 dollar worth of copper or plastic scrap, no matter how cheap the shipping.  So we start with the assumption that net payment for uniform products is a commodity, and then deduce what unintended, unwanted junk might be "toxics along for the ride". If the product is commingled, you are less sure.

Here is a decision tree, as it is written in a fair trade negotiation with Techs of Color.

DEMAND-CENTRIC DECISION TREE


We recognize that flows of tested working equipment may be waste, and do not consider the "working" or "functional" test to be a reason to avoid any of the questions below.  Our decision tree is based on the final outcomes, and employs factors like demand, skill, and demonstrated capability of the buyer, not just the tests and opinions of the generator.

1) Is the importer capable of recycling electronics created by incidental breakage or eventual end-of-life?
If yes, continue


2)  Are the recycling processes for the end- of -life parts and takebacks legal and safe?
If yes, continue, if no establish returns program for trans-shipping (we consider the incidental breakage and takeback to have been generated in the importing country, the same as import of brand new equipment for assembly may be damaged or faulty and is considered generated at the assembly plant, not an illegal shipment of waste).

3) Does the exporter agree to cover the costs of reconciling necessary post-reconciliation?
If yes, continue
4) Does the importer maintain inventory and purchase orders forecasting demand and reuse potential for imported electronics?
If yes, continue

5) Does the importer notify the exporter to stop shipments which are in surplus / out of demand?
If yes, continue, if NO, go back to #2.

6) Does the competent Commerce Department* of the importing country consider the imports to be commodities, not waste? 

If yes, continue*

* Note, whether or not your goods are new or used, fully functional or for repair, another nation may classify them otherwise.  Once the goods are in a country that labels them waste or discards, EPA is the competent authority, unless you are ready to file an appeal with WTO (which does handle these issues - countries have tried to use waste laws for protectionist reasons in several other commodities, and WTO has heard cases about the control of steel and copper scrap, for example).

While the "commodity" is still in the USA, so long as you keep the goods dry (treat them like commodities) EPA cannot easily enter your home or business to seize goods.  And this is also true in many other nations.  Unless the nation considers the goods to be waste, trade treaties under WTO govern the material.

However, some nations (like China) classify all "second-hand" products as "waste" (regardless of whether they pass the Basle flow diagram).  Nigeria has protectionist laws to protect shoe manufacturing factories, and considers used shoes imports "illegal".  Even in the USA, if imported working electronic goods are considered black market (e.g., violating intellectual property laws), etc., the Customs Department may insist those working goods be destroyed, creating waste.  There have been some countries which create a separate category for CRTs refurbished for re-export;  even China allowed certain contract manufacturers to continue used CRT refurbishing within special "trade zones", like Maquila Dora areas of Mexico (where Mexico Customs does not consider the product to be "imported", but requires it to leave Mexico.

This long footnote on legality is not specific to either R2 or E-Stewards or federal CRT Rule.  R2 insists that the exports be legal in the country of import, even if the legality is not based on environmental reasons.  If a dictator seizes working equipment to keep citizens off of the internet, and they are discarded, then they will have been discarded and be waste.  (As a stakeholder at R2, I protested non-environmental laws being incorporated into R2, but lost the vote.)

If another nation considers working CRTs to be waste, it's a grey area for USA EPA... since they were shipped legally for reuse, but you cannot have the 3 years of record keeping demonstrating they were indeed reused without creating problems for your buyer. You creat a problem for yourself if the goods are seized and destroyed.  The safest thing is to make sure BOTH that they will be reused AND that the country of import is not calling second-hand-goods "waste".  When our USA customs seizes and destroys black market goods, they become waste, and your exports may suffer a similar fate.  This is why WR3A does not export CRTs, working or not, to China, even though we have qualified excellent CRT factories working there.

(Where were we?  Ahem ..If yes, continue)


7)  Does the importer agree to pay more for the commodities than the net value of scrap minus transportation costs?

If yes, continue. 

If no, the load should be witnessed by a third party to make sure that the goods are not being brought in for cherry picking of copper and possible discard of toxics along for the ride.  I would not disqualify all buyers based on this, as they sometimes simply want to compete with competitors who have lowered their prices.  But it should demand more scrutiny if you are exporting for less-than-or-equal-to scrap (e.g. copper) value.

8)  Does the CRT contain cadmium (review MSDS records)?
Because Basel considers glass recycling to require hazardous phosphors be removed, and CRTs might be damaged in handling, WR3A has created a database to exclude any CRTs that contain cadmium phosphors, working or not, from export out of OECD.

If no, GO AHEAD 

 EXPORT and OBTAIN RECONCILIATION REPORT, MASS BALANCE, ETC.
If all of these questions allow the export, you still aren't clear with WR3A.   We require a written purchase order which lists individual items which the importer does and doesn't want.  If the CRT importer wants equipment we know to be non-functional, we visit and site audit to determine they have the capacity to repair, reuse and properly recycle the equipment.

WR3A financially incentivizes importers who take extra steps, e.g. getting ISO14001, ISO9000, insurance, or who take back ("cash for clunkers" style) junk electronics in their own country... but we would not consider those legal requirements.

I started my company by plugging in and proving each monitor worked.  Then I made a site visit, and discovered that one common type of monitor I had been shipping, while fully functional, was not in demand in the country I'd shipped to.

Sitting in an Asian buyer's car, as he drove me to the airport, he said,
"I won't lie to you.  We will throw those away.  I don't care what happens to them, I don't want them.  Don't send them to us, and we won't throw them away.  There are people who will tell you they reuse those, but they don't.  I don't lie, I don't play games."

That was a year before WR3A held its first meeting.  I wanted to establish an association which was more transparent and open, which encouraged fair trade between buyers and sellers.  The solution was not for me to pay people to test monitors, but to find out how the reuse market decides what to buy and send only that.  And we came up with the idea to get reports back on every shipment, and to pay the full cost of recycling anything that we missed.

This method of export reconciliation has not been warmly received by BAN.  But it cannot be said that we are exporting 80% illegal waste.  We have the entire records of reuse of every shipment, and we have blind loads shipped as "tested working" from several suppliers.  We have "CRT glass test" results on the delivery of CRT cullet, etc.  The question has been, do we just declare our exports are "tested working"?  Or do we give credit to the skills of Techs of Color?

The decision tree .for used battery exports doesn't work well for laptops and CRT monitors."Working" does not mean "non-waste" and "non-working" does not mean "waste"... given the choice between the price offered on two different laptops, and the declaration that one is working and one is not, the price predicts the waste.  We need geeks to describe the flow of material from the point of view of nations who repair.

Decision Tree: Basel Convention on Functionality


Worst Reuse of a Computer
With the best of intentions, NGOs and representatives of Parties to the Basel Convention have designed a "decision tree" or flow chart to regulate the sale of used and surplus computers to emerging economies in developing nations.  The strongest opinions expressed about the "Decision Tree" were submitted by Basel Action Network (BAN) an industry watchdog which describes its opinion of "export for repair" in this 2008 paper, Preventing the Digital Dump:  Ending Re-Use Abuse.  It lays out the basis for BAN and other NGOs breaking away from the interpretation of "repair" language in the Basle Convention interpreted by EPA, WR3A and R2.   It's well written, and its flow diagram case for "tested working" and "fully functional" deserves scholarly attention.

The flow chart in BAN's paper appears to be based on a battery flow chart or a fluorescent lamp flow chart.   Test it and see if it works before you sell it.  That's where EPA started in the 1990s, before the more recent CRT Rule.  It's attractive for its simplicity.  When implemented, it would indeed reduce the number of bad units in a random load of collected computers.  Unfortunately, it fails where it should stop the export of bad PCs, and also arrests exports of some good equipment.  A computer is not a light bulb.

Electronics are more complex in their functions - involving software, magnetism in different hemispheres, upgrade availability, and demand fluctuations.  Because of the complexity, the degree of human skill level becomes the determinative factor in whether a PC results in "waste" (disposal or discard of components which bear Annex III toxics, forbidden in Annex VII).   I'm going to split this blog into two parts.  First I'll look at how "functionality" tests fail to stop some wastes, where testing doesn't guarantee that no waste is produced.  In a future post, I'll describe how "functionality" tests create false positives for waste - there are many repairs which produce no discards at all, and treating these repairs as exactly the same as dumping will cause the USA to destroy working products in high demand.

The BAN decision tree may be better than nothing.  But in at least in some cases, shocker of shockers, the free market does a better job of preserving value and limiting waste than the "command and control" of used electronics exports.  We hope to arrive at export rules 3.0 in the coming year.

The question is, can we safely depart from a simple test, like BAN has prescribed, without opening the barn door to rationalization, fraud, pretext and abuse?   WR3A's proposal is to take a system which doesn't even reuse material BAN would accept, California, and then properly track the equipment California companies propose to ship, and see which materials got reused and which ones were junk.  If we ship California monitors to the same refurbishing factories, replacing WR3A supplies, we can then look historically and compare how well the new E-Stewards suppliers do compared to historical shipments, tested for repairability and need (getting the right volume is half the battle).  Both organizations will make progress if we rely on people smarter than me.  Techs of Color. 

Part I:  Tested Working product produces waste.   The BAN paper, in reaction to piles of e-waste on foreign shores, correctly describes how repair can become a pretext for exporting harm.  My problem is that if they shut down supplies and don't replace them, it's a "war on drugs" approach which creates bad traffic.  But aside from that, if the decision tree works as it is designed, can't it also provide the same pretexts?

To illustrate how well the BAN rules work logically, lets take some examples.  I'll just grant that a smashed or cancelled tube with the vacuum released - as is required by California law - will not get exported, and that BAN's rules will capture the worst examples of junk exports in its net.   But let's also look at 3 computers which pass all the functionality tests designed by groups such as E-Stewards.

"Internet-free,  color-blind" market
Software Issue:   The first computer is a working, functional Macintosh SE computer, made in 1992.  All of its programs work.  But it does not run java script, which means it is useless on most web sites.  A few may sell, but these are not going to be sold by the thousands in a nation which needs internet, and an importer who winds up with them is more than likely going to scrap them.

If you can read this you're too close
Degaussing Issue:  The second computer is a fully functional, tested working computer with a 2003 computer monitor which has had a good 3 hour burn in test.  It worked when it left the USA,  but  it won't work when it arrives in the southern hemisphere. CRT manufacturers made CRTs for either northern hemisphere, southern hemisphere, or neutral (equator), and there will be a picture distortion that makes text  illegible.  There are several fixes for this, from putting a magnet near the monitor to taking the monitor apart, flipping the tube, and reversing the wires.  The point is that if the CRT is not sold to a technician (like WR3A works with), the person receiving the computer may think it doesn't work.  Computers which are fully functional may still demand repairs.


"Los gringos agradable dejado algunos desechos funcionales para nosotros"
Elective Upgrade Issue:  The third computer, also tested and fully functional, is sold with two sticks of 256k RAM memory.  The retail buyer, unknown to the USA / EU shipper, is savvy about computers and elects to replace the two sticks of RAM with two sticks of 512k RAM.  He doubles the memory of the computer and discards or recycles the two sticks of RAM.

These are not the only three examples of a repair, a recycling, or disposal "slipping through the cracks" of the decision tree model insisted on by Basel Action Network.  TVs with analogue signals for USA can be exported to PAL or SECAM countries.  Power supplies designed for 110 volt USA current may all be working, but they won't be used in a 220v country.  And warranty repairs for used electronics manufactured in China cannot be legally refused under WTO agreements.

We do not want to panic and try to redesign a flow chart to further restrict trade as a solution to these problems.  The best outcome is a "fair trade" agreement between prospective suppliers (e.g. R2 or E-Steward "e-waste" recycling companies) and repair people (e.g. WR3A and TechSoup Global parterns) in the developing world.  WR3A drafts very detailed contracts, explaining how many of THESE and how many of THOSE computers a buyer can handle, and requiring the buyer to prove they can handle the types of refurbishing that may be warranted.

Binding civil law contracts are used to avoid sending obsolete but "working" products (example A), to ensure the buyer in the south has capacity to degauss the CRTs (a routine and simple repair for WR3A partners and contract manufacturers), and to require proper recycling of electively replaced parts, like the RAM in the computer they have upgraded in example C.  These techs can be given incentives to do these things correctly, and to recycle properly in safe and humane conditions.

What I have learned, as a student of international relations, as a Peace Corps volunteer, as director of a non-profit recycling organization, as a recycling regulator, and as a small business person, is that the skill of a person creates value in an object.   No matter how perfectly working a computer is, it will be useless in a village without electricity.  And no matter how few Americans refuse to repair a cell phone, more people in emerging countries will choose to repair it.  One man's trash is another man's treasure.  But the use of a decision tree makes the "trasher" man the judge.


Good intentions set up a decision tree which treats a computer like an light bulb - good or bad, black/white.  But the process of marketing that model of improvement involved denigration of opponents, casting the world in a black vs. white map of "exporters" and "stewards".   The truth is that repair and refurbishing is sometimes NOT a pretext, and the buyers are smarter than you think.

Technicians in Ghana, Indonesia, Egypt and Pakistan need to meet the people drawing the diagram.  The problem is Americans with strong opinions on either side - pro export or anti-export - may never fly over to Guiyu or Shenzhen or Accra or Semarang or Mumbai or Cairo.  They may never meet the people who are going to burn or degauss the monitors, and never get feedback on the quality of goods - either "as is" or "tested working" - which they ship.  If they have their cell phone repaired in New York or Paris, of course, they are extremely unlikely to encounter a WASP.

The Basel Convention allows Parties (countries) to interpret whether a repair is definitely legal under Annex IX  B1110, or counts as "major reassembly" (not allowed).  The environmental officials in these countries have other choices than to keep their people offline (though some I suspect consider that a benefit), or to continue to rely on white people to make new computers for them. The representatives of the Parties are getting to see lots of pictures of kids sitting in ash piles, but they are not getting to meet Techs of Color.

Without question, the people I trade with in developing nations are smarter about technology, reuse and repair, and in many cases recycling as well, than the "nanny state" regulators who try to protect them from buying the equipment they need and can afford.  The fact that Hamdy knows more than Robin Ingenthron or Shiela Davis or Jim Pucket about laptop repairs is a fact, not an opinion.  The mistake is to treat Hamdy as equivalent of the people who burn computers for copper wire.  Had we spoken to Hamdy before designing the diagram, we would have less scrap being burned in the first place.

Free and Fair Trade between educated people in different countries is kick ass.  What we need is hard numbers.  I can state with precision how many of the 300,000 computer monitors I shipped needed repair, how many were working, what the value was of each, and what happened to accidental breakage in shipping and human error.

I'd like to see those numbers from the Stewards.  How many "tested working" did they ship, and the breakdown of how the residue was managed.  If their system is better, and I'm wrong, California will show it.


In Part II, I'll share more of the details about how the WR3A's sophisticated trade model provides data, and that the data allows us to respond to minute changes in market demand, and that reduces net discarded waste.   WR3A sees people for what they can do, not for what they cannot do.   Vicki in Mexico, Jinex in Peru, Souleymane in Senegal, Su Fung in Asia - they are not my equals.  They are my superiors.   I have equipment they want, and they are willing to pay far more than the value of metal scrap for that equipment.  This demands rigorous and enforceable fair trade contracts.  I'd like my buyers to be able to call BAN if WR3A ships them junky product, without fear that their sophisticated repair and recycling capacity will be held against them.

I basically think that the complexity a repair job  gives advantage to skilled people in emerging nations.   Rich nations don't need the skill, and are designing systems based on what we are willing to do, not what the Techs of Color are ABLE to do..  Too many recyclers prefer to put money in a shredding machine than to hire an American to plug devices in - and in California, if they do sell a working device, they are punished severely through lost subsidies.  This is where BAN and WR3A have an opportunity to work together... taking California's big stupid system, and running computer monitors tested to e-Steward specifications, and running them through WR3A Fair Trade vendor reconciliation programs.

Ghost Tonnage, an E-waste Recycling Powderkeg

    Unicor's E-Waste Stewardship Director?
This ewaste legislation prediction kind of went unnoticed, but I've seen, heard, and smelled this activity...   As described last year in a Good Point Blogpost "Ghost Tonnage", E-waste "command and control" programs are skewing the marketplace:
  1. State requires Manufacturers to account for an Arbitrary E-waste recovery number per year (e.g. RI, MN, VT), based on current or past sales.
  2. OEMs obtain bids from several recyclers.
  3. Recyclers who collect more actual e-waste ("sweat tonnage") than OEM require are stuck with "orphan tonnage":  Ewaste they don't get reimbursed for.
  4. Recyclers who 'close one eye', i.e. accept non covered tonnage or state border tonnage have both a price and risk advantage (e.g., I have to pay guys to remove printers from loads in Rhode Island, if I eliminate those staff, my weights go up).
  5. Recyclers who make up ghost numbers (add a zero on a truck weight) can sell their "tonnage" to OEMs for less money and have no actual risk of orphan material.
  6. The Recyclers who make up numbers increase the risk of those actually collecting. Ghost tonnage displaces sweat tonnage, creating "orphan tonnage".
  7. Result will be states increasing OEM obligation to take care of orphan tonnage???  Go back to 1
The winners will be companies who broker tonnage. It's like Bernie Madoff needs to get into the E-Waste business.  Unicor, you have a big opportunity here!

It's a vicious cycle, created by arbitrary "command and control" legislation.  It will quickly reach a point where recyclers are surrounded by "OEM Assigned" commitments they need to fill, or be put out of business.  At that point I'll probably sell Good Point Recycling to leave with my integrity intact, as it will become impossible to collect 100 tons of TVs and charge 20 cents per pound when another recycler CLAIMS to have collected 200 tons of TVs and charges 10 cents per pound, and a third recycler claims to have collected 400 tons of TVs and charges 5 cents per pound.

If an honest recycler blows the whistle, he/she is injuring a group of Manufacturers who never asked to get into this business, they were legislated into it.  They watch growing market share of new electronics products made by unknown or invisible Chinese companies who don't have a clue.  If I own stock in the OEM, I guess I'd want them to shrug, buy ghost tonnage, and hope that the Stewardship Laws serve as a Japan-style non-tariff barrier to entry in USA sales markets.  If the secondary market loses material that might have gone into the gray market, it wasn't my intention but I'll take it.  If stuff gets recycled, cool.

The states with these "command and control" version Stewardship Laws will soon be stuck in the position that CIWMB / CalRecycles found itself in, chasing after pieces of paper... or just declaring victory and publishing they have collected 400 tons at 5 cents a pound and recommending other states pass the same laws.

Safe Search for Ten Year Olds

The internet image search... I can spend hours.  The clip at bottom is from a Nasa 2010 closeup of the sun.  (No! below the dog.)

My youngest son yesterday was asking me about dog breeds.  He said he liked the one in the movie "Babe 2:  Pig in the City" which, he said, had the face "like this" (he makes a face thinking it will look like the dog's face... ok right), "You know, Papa, the dog whose face was thin and long."

I wondered if it was a poodle or an afghan, he said no (he knows those).   He said it was the dog that falls in the canal, the mean dog that Babe the pig rescues.

So I thought, I'd go to google images or bing images and search "babe" and "dog" and see with my son what popped up.

"Babe" + "dog" = Oops.
I'm now a convert to "safe search" option.  Talk about unintended consequences!   I closed the laptop in time, I think.  (It's a bull terrier).

China Mining Deaths: Another Reason to Recycle

Recycling an aluminum can saves enough energy to fill the can 2/3 full of gasoline... it saves 95% of the energy it takes to make the can from mining and scratch.   And that's true whether the can is recycled in China, India, Japan, Europe or the USA.  Yes, Recycling is good for China.
  • Recycling reduces energy use in China.
  • Recycling reduces toxics from metal mining in China.
  • Recycling reduces coal mining deaths in China.
  • Recycling creates jobs in China..

The table below offers more data, courtesy of the Natural Resources Defense Council [NRDC].  The energy and carbon reduction make recycling one of the most important activities we can undertake for global sustainability.

Add to that yet another report, from BBC, on how horrible mining is in China.  Chinese mining deaths, per 10,000 miners, is 100x the fatality of the USA.  Chinese today are awed that Chile is going to such effort to rescue metal miners stuck underground - in China, miners seem almost disposable.

Question:  If the Chinese are dying by mining for the coal energy, and if metal mining releases hundreds of times more toxicity than metal recycling, and the Chinese are the best at reuse and repair, and they need jobs... just exactly how bad can "recycling in China" be?

It is essential that Fair Trade programs roll up their sleeves and invest in Chinese recycling, clean up their acts, give them incentives and training, and get recycling into order.   A boycott condemns China to mining and refining, coal and smelting.

Why not reward the best recyclers China has (and I have seen incredibly good Chinese recyclers), and overcome the worst recycling practices with free market, fair trade, incentives and training?

China has 16,000 active mines - most of which are illegal   Saving energy and providing recycled metals seems a lesser sin than making them use the coal to cyanide/smelt the metals for the products we buy, made in China.

I prefer to "buy recycled", even when "made in China".
Top of Report

Tables

Table 1: Energy Savings and CO2 Impacts
Recycling and Incineration

Energy Savings Per Ton Recycled

Energy Generated
Per Ton Incinerated

Materials Grade % Reduction of Energy* Million BTUs Equivalent in Barrels of Oil Tons CO2 Reduced Million BTUs Equivalent in Barrels of Oil
Aluminum
95 196 37.2 13.8 -1.06 -0.2
Paper** Newsprint
Print/Writing
Linerboard
Boxboard
45
35
26
26.
20.9
20.8
12.3
12.8
3.97
3.95
2.34
2.43
-0.03
-0.03
0.07
0.04
11.8
11.8
11.8
11.8
2.24
2.24
2.24
2.24
Glass Recycle
Reuse
31
328
4.74
50.18
0.9
9.54
0.39
3.46
-0.34
na
-0.06
na
Steel
61 14.3 2.71 1.52 -0.34 -0.06
Plastic PET
PE
PP
57
75
74
57.9
56.7
53.6
11
10.8
10.2
0.985
0.346
1.32
35.9
35.9
38.5
6.8
6.8
7.3
Mixed MSW
na na na na 10 1.9
Estimates derived from data supplied by Argonne National Labs (1980, 1981), DOE (1982),
Franklin Associates (1990), AL Associates, AISI, Phillips 66, Wellman (1991). Conversions
based on data from Love (1974), CRC (1978), Perry (1984), EIS (1990).

* Relative to energy required for virgin production
** Energy calculations for paper recycling count unused wood as fuel
na = not applicable