These are coming out so quickly now. I think this is a movement. As the NPR article reports, the reactions against "poverty porn", "parasites of the poor", "accidental racism" and "boycotts of geeks of color" are not something I'm making up.
I have heard the frustrating cries from the technicians in Asia, Africa, and South America for over a decade.
This video parody shows Africans coming together, a la "We are the World", to donate radiators to poor freezing Norwegian children. The way Norway is presented does have a grain of truth... it is indeed cold there, and the cold is something that would really seem frightening to Africans. But they hit the out-of-context, Onion-esque, clueless notes that anti-export organizations don't seem aware of...
At FastCoExist.com, Ariel Schwartz and Nathaniel Whittenmore describe some of the same lessons I thought we learned in the 1960s, about "poster child syndrome" (the UNICEF campaign). From Ariel's article:
E-Waste Poster Children are everywhere.
I'm still working on the individual examples for the "legal malpractice" case. It's just something I want to be very careful with, something that has to be done right.
More from the NPR article about the video, below.
I have heard the frustrating cries from the technicians in Asia, Africa, and South America for over a decade.
This video parody shows Africans coming together, a la "We are the World", to donate radiators to poor freezing Norwegian children. The way Norway is presented does have a grain of truth... it is indeed cold there, and the cold is something that would really seem frightening to Africans. But they hit the out-of-context, Onion-esque, clueless notes that anti-export organizations don't seem aware of...
At FastCoExist.com, Ariel Schwartz and Nathaniel Whittenmore describe some of the same lessons I thought we learned in the 1960s, about "poster child syndrome" (the UNICEF campaign). From Ariel's article:
"Guilt-tripping is still a commonly used tactic in trying to get people to donate money for the impoverished, though it is slowly being replaced by more hopeful messages from organizations like Mama Hope and Pencils of Promise. Nathaniel Whittemore explains in a Co.Exist post from earlier this year that this is strategic: "It supposes that after decades of being battered over the head by relief organizations flaunting horror images, there’s not much left but table scraps in the guilt bucket," he writes.Fair Trade Recycling is a movement to recognize the crazy good things about repair and trade and even recycling in the emerging markets. I could never have predicted the animosity directed towards technicians and recyclers in emerging markets, promoted by the very people I hung out with in college. Remember the "boycott" of Fair Trade Cotton at Victoria's secret?
E-Waste Poster Children are everywhere.
I'm still working on the individual examples for the "legal malpractice" case. It's just something I want to be very careful with, something that has to be done right.
More from the NPR article about the video, below.
"The video is humorous, but there is a serious message. The point is that images of helpless Africans are just as inaccurate as the idea of helpless freezing Norwegians. A lot of Africans cannot relate to the patronizing videos and development initiatives."
"The organization says it has certain goals with the video. "
"Among them that fundraising "should not be based on exploiting stereotypes" and that media should have more respect in portraying suffering children."
No comments:
Post a Comment