Story Lines: Social Myth Pollution

The diagram below traces the storylines of different mythologies, from the ancient Greeks to the Romans, etc.  There probably never was a "Cyclops", but once you get enough people to retell the story, it can take much more than decades to relegate it to myth buster bins.  Greek storylines are NOT a schematic diagram.

Environmentalists are on this dangerous edge...  We want awareness of our concern, about rain forests, pollution, extinction, and unsustainable growth.   The rate of change of all of these fields is alarming, and we are desperate for any news story that boosts momentum for our cause.

Environmental Health, or Ecology, is definitely a science.  But it is a young science.   We have not been able to measure the earth climate and biosphere for as long as we've been able to measure mass and volume (physics) or chemistry or biology.

When there is a new science, the field is open to people declaring themselves "experts".  I would postulate that you get some really good scientists who recognize an emerging field and get into it with great contributions.  But it would be tempting for a scientist who was weak in their chosen field to change games.  And there would be a less mature group of peer reviewers to catch the "Tiggers" (A.A. Milne character, a new stuffed animal who attracts a lot of attention by making lots of pronouncements... it takes a little bit for the other animals to figure out Tigger's angle).

What is especially dangerous is when a non-scientist, e.g. a "social scientist" (I got a degree in Poli-Sci and International Relations, so I'm outing myself here) jumps into the void.   What is incredibly dangerous is when the social scientist or poser gets funding based on headlines.  They become a "headline generator", and this propagates myths.

The best social scientists will explain that Japan, Taiwan, Korea, Singapore, Shenzhen - all the areas which have seen the fastest social progress in human history - did so by recycling, then repairing, then grey marketing, then contract manufacturing, then... becoming Acer, Samsung, Seagate, etc.

To take the same path of progress away from Egypt and the rest of Africa is major experimental surgery.  Egypt is the most likely Mid-East or African country to emerge as a manufacturing economy.  Islamic superpower democracies of the East - Indonesia, Singapore, and Malaysia - all began with refurbishment and recycling of electronics and emerged as economic tigers.  

Having lived in Africa, I'm very sensitive to the need to protect the environment.  But I know that mining (the only opponent and opposite of recycling) is the true danger to the rain forests and fauna.  I also know that if you take the boys away from sorting copper wire, that the real choices left to them are not to win on "Who Wants to be a Millionaire".  They are more likely to sell a kidney, or die in a field of nyams at the age of 50.

There is a tremendous opportunity for young environmentalists to study and throw out the Myths.   They are like dangerous unstable cornerstones.   The professors in the field of climate change are quickly learning to be very aware of the double-edge sword of publicity.  They are forming a united peer review front and holding "global warming" and "climate change" essays to the fire, to make sure information is tested and true.

"Eighty Percent of used electronics exports are burned in primitive wire burning operations"... This is a cancerous lie.  This myth has been wrong since it cropped up in 2002, and our field of recycling needs to be ashamed of itself for allowing this myth to hang on as long as it has.   I can name the culprits in a future post, there are plenty of people who believe it, but also many who know it for what it is but repeat it to boost their selfish interests.

My point today is that there is indeed a major need to reform and develop overseas markets.  There is a need to keep poisonous processes out of the hands of children and desperate parents.  But placing a false cornerstone will ultimately undermine the entire field.  E-Steward Certification, Responsible Recyclers, and Environmental Justice are going to be set back if they take the easy path and publish a fake number.

80% is a completely fake number.  Sarah at BAN told me her source was a Ghana journalist.  He told me his source was BAN.   As a peer reviewing friend, truth may sting, but you have to stop telling people that 80% is primitive burning if your actual objection to USA EPA policy is that a tiny 1/2 inch capacitor with no toxic elements is being replaced and properly recycled, and you consider that process of replacing a capacitor and recycling it to be a violation of the Basel Convention, and that therefore the 80% of computers - which yield less than a kilo of replaced capacitors - is illegal and primitive.

BAN.org objects to repair because a tiny capacitor or part might be recycled (properly), and maintains it is a violation of the Basel Convention.  The Basel Convention explicitly allows export for repair and refurbishment.  BAN even objects to the Convention.  It says neither "fully functional" nor "tested working".  And while BAN says that "in the future" Europe will require "tested working", that is nothing less in its claim (true or not) as it is an admission the Convention does NOT say so.

The "Story of Stuff" riffs on Electronics

Ok, I do think these Stuff videos by Annie Leonard are nifty and very accessible.   But with great power, comes great responsibility.  Here is the newly released 7+ minute video they've put out on "The Story of Electronics".  I'll follow with some commentary.




First, I like that they begin with mining.    But they don't show the toxics that come out of mining.   Did you know that gold mining produces more mercury (as a bi-product) than MERCURY mining???  So I'm glad they started there, but they didn't really tell much of a story about it.  There is way more toxics, carbon, pollution, extinction and death in the beginning of the product lifecycle than at the disposal end. 

Had they recognized the harm of extraction, they may have caught their first fallacy... "Toxics In = Toxics Out."  So simple, but so Untrue.  The rarer the metal you are mining (gold, paladium, silver, tin), the more toxics enter the environment.  It is the process of mining and refining that creates pollution, not the toxicity of the final distilled product.  Replacing lead in solder with Tin, for example, may reduce the amount of lead in a rich country's lined landfill, but it will increase the lead and mercury (mining biproducts) in the places - like Indonesian coral islands - where they mine the tin.

Then, the video makes it look like the factories that make the Stuff are in the rich countries, and the junk is dumped in the poor countries.  Actually, Guiyu is close to Shenzhen.  Shenzhen China is where all the Ipods and laptops and PC boards are made, by contract manufacturers.  Most of the junk in Guiyu comes from employees in Shenzhen, who tend to own computers and to throw them out.  Hong Kong is also in the area, and it's one of the wealthiest cities in the world, with 7 million people throwing away "Stuff".

Third, they simplistically try showing that if the manufacturer has to take the Stuff back, that will be a solution.   Actually, it is the manufacturers who ARE taking the Stuff back.  Plastics go back to China, copper goes back to China, steel and aluminum and repairable CRTs all find their way back to the factories making Stuff.  It is PRECISELY BECAUSE that is where the manufacturing is, that is where the skill is, that is where demand is.

If "externalizing costs" was indeed the big explanation, couldn't we dump Stuff in the ocean, or send it to Haiti (which is poorer than China)?  Cost externalization doesn't explain which ports the material goes to - raw material demand does.

StoryOfStuff.org is very talented and no doubt means well, and in many places they are great at capturing a complicated problem and making it understandable.  But with great power comes great responsibility.  It is not a bad film.  But it reflects insular thinking, groupthink, and emerges as propaganda not journalism.

This is the central theme of this Ethical "E-Waste" blog...


Western medicine is the best in the world, but not because the history of western hospitals is pretty.  Actually, from bleeding and leeching and burning people, to feeding spoonfuls of mercury to King Edward (as a laxative, I think), our history of cures is pretty awful.  But what saved western health care was peer review.  Being truthful, publishing findings, scientific method.  People studied the cures that were being peddled.  They collected data and took notes.   And they changed practices, causing western medicine to evolve.


My pain comes from environmental science which does not evolve.   We have a lot of film explaining how CRT contract manufacturing companies in Asia have been buying back the used CRTs, how white box manufacturing overseas is buying up used computers, and that the legitimate reuse of used equipment is the economic engine for the export market.  I'd like to see the community respond to those slide shows, point out where I may be mistaken, and return the favor of truth.

Apology Presented... It's a good study

I woke up this morning and one of the first things I did was to reopen the study posted about "E-Waste" processing in Ghana.   I am trying to find a French language version, so that I can share it with Jean Frederic Fahiri Somda, the attorney (and former Attorney General) of Burkina Faso who stayed in Middlebury at my home for 6 months, researching international law about "commodities", "wastes", "process wastes", points of generation, etc.  The report by Andreas Manhart and Siddharth Prakash deserves attention and it's a big mistake on my part to "poison the well" by implying it's difficult to read.

In looking for the link to the study, I went to my blog, and I was embarrassed by the "Blah-blah" I originally put in the title (I was looking for a way to shorten the actual title of the report, which didn't fit in the Blog Title part, and I tritely put in "blah-blah" in my own post).  In doing so, I was making light of the study, while at the same time rereading it and gobbling it up.  A tad hypocritical, I might say.  Was it not me who called for more scientific and academic research at the Interpol forum in DC last summer?

The study basically needs to define "e-waste" at the very beginning as being non-commodity, non-reuse.  Except for the slight misstep in defining the EOL equipment, it's actually one of the best studies written.  I apologize for making light of it in my descriptions of academic writing. It adds to the scholarly thesis written by Brenda Wijnen, the WR3A intern who wrote a paper on "Fair Trade" approaches to e-scrap exports, and bolsters the paper written in French by Mr. Fred Somda.

How well could I write the paper in Dutch?   Even French, a language I know, would be a major challenge.  What an ugly American I am this week.

There needs to be even more research.  I presented a thesis in this blog that an export load of CRTs (TVs or monitors) needs to be at least 70% repairable or functional to be economically repeatable, based on shipping costs to West Africa and value of scrap in the load.  This study is better written than my post, and moves this discussion forward.  I hope it's not too late, and I hope other readers don't repeat my mistake and write dismissively of studies they haven't had time to consider carefully.

Socio-Economic ... um... E-waste Management in Ghana

If you can read it, you will find Proof of Concept of our Fair Trade model.

I've been reading this report by Andreas Manhart and Siddharth Prakash on the situation in Ghana. This is a slightly edited post... I was in a hurry to post a link to this study and tried to cover up that I hadn't been able to read it in one sitting by making fun of it... something I will apologize for in my next post.

The report is written in Dutch-ish and you need a good strong half cup of coffee to get very far (too much coffee and you won't be able to sit through a paragraph).   Fortunately, I am married to an academic and read social engineering and international academic writings in College. What the basically says is that taking screws out and separating metals from plastics and other metals may be appropriate work in an African nation that desperately needs jobs. 
"Therefore, the business is suitable to be implemented within the current informal recycling sector in Ghana."
This is important.

It is refreshing to read a report which actually acknowledges the importance of employment in the country of Ghana.   It is refreshing to see the economics of even "informal" e-scrap recycling (the kindlier word for "primitive") put in a way which is different from the "free them from toxics and they will eat cake" utopian approach you see in the USA.  There are a few things, such as printed wiring boards, which may need to be re-exported.   But that's true in the USA too, is it not?

The report also makes an honest effort to describe hand disassembly and recycling, and is refreshing in pointing out that disassembly of a computer is not intrinsically "toxic" as an activity.
"Although desktop computers contain quite a variety of hazardous substances, none of these substances is present as liquid or a gas.  This makes the proper transport and pre-processing of waste desktop computers quite manageable..."
The paper does come much closer to describing some of the activities in e-scrap management which have been skimmed over by "advocacy" papers.  It describes "deep manual dismantling" (what we do at Retroworks de Mexico), where recycling requires "high labour intensity".

I think the paper comes up short in describing the difference in employment between repair and reuse and refurbishment.  Value added analysis in the USA tends to place the employment in repair at 100 times that of recycling, and employment in recycling as 100 times the value of employment from disposal.  Two of the first 10 billionaires in China were repairmen (bicycles and tractors), and the founder of Acer (owner of Gateway, second largest PC manufacturer worldwide) began in the SKD computer monitor refurbishing business.  You don't see many wire burning people reach that kind of economic influence.

It takes brains and savvy to repair and refurbish PCs.  I'm afraid the paper treats repair of computers - like those filmed by WR3A in Egypt, Senegal, Indonesia, Peru, and Malaysia - as too close to informal management of residue.

However, it does make a great stride in answering the question, "if this work is taken away, what will these people do", in a more comprehensive way than BAN responded to 60 Minutes ("They shouldn't have to make that choice.")

The report also fails to question some myths, e.g. "the internal phosphorous coating of the front contains cadmium".  This is basically false statement.  Cadmium was used in the 1960s first-generation color phosphors.  There is some ytrium in modern phosphors, but the report should call for an actual study of the release of toxics, as compared to the toxins released in burning of fuel to move stuff about and mine new metals.

There is actually a lot more to delve deeply into the report, and I intend to revisit it a few more times.

E-Waste Money for Nothing

Wanted:  Environmentalist with video editing software and a sense of humor.  

I was driving a truckload of computers, TVs, printers etc. from a Rhode Island "E-waste" event late Saturday night, zigging through the Green Mountains back to our recycling plant in Middlebury Vermont around midnight.  Hurting and feeling good at the same time.  And this song comes on the radio [Thank You Mark Knopfler and Dire Straits]  And I realize, hey!  This is our ewaste collection song!!



Over ten years ago I made my first speech about electronics recycling policy at the EPR2 conference in Washington DC.  I opened by saying that "electronics recycling" appears to be just like every other kind of recycling in one way - the people who make a career of talking about it earn more than you can by doing it.  (That was a reference to the gap between policy wonks and people on the scrap dis-assembly lines...)

What I'd like is to do a cover of this majestic Dire Straits "Money for Nothing" song with a few twists*.

Now look at them yo-yo's that's the way you do it
You talk about "e-waste" policy
That ain't workin' that's the way you do it
Money for nothin' and checks for free
Now that ain't workin' that's the way you do it
Lemme tell ya them guys ain't dumb
Maybe get a blister on your little finger
Maybe get a blister on your tongue.

We gotta haul out microwave ovens

E-waste takeback and deliveries
We gotta move these laser printers
We gotta move these colour TV's

See the bureaucrat with the necktie or the makeup

Yeah buddy that's his own hair
That bureaucrat got his own new Prius
That little brat he's a millionaire

We gotta takeout microwave ovens

E-waste takeback deliveries
We gotta move these refrigerators
We gotta move these colour TV's

I shoulda learned to make e-waste law

I shoulda learned to write regulation

Look at that mama, she's clickin' with the camera
Makin' this look like fun
And who's up there, what's that? Exporting noises?
Bangin' on the keyboard like a chimpanzee
That ain't workin' that's the way you do it
Get your money for nothin' get your checks for free

We gotta deman microwave ovens

E-waste Event deliveries
We gotta move these televisions
We gotta teardown these old PC's, Lord

Now that ain't workin' that's the way you do it

You speak about e-waste policy
That ain't workin' that's the way you do it
Money for nothin' and your checks for free
Money for nothin' and checks for free 


Since first posting this on Sunday, I got an eyebrow-raising comment (see "Anonymous" below") about part of the Mark Knopfler song I had not re-written.   It turns out that direct reuse of lyrics (which contained the words "that little faggot") had a toxic effect on some readers.  I've re-written the lyrics above (in the same way as I suspect a NY eco-lobbyist re-wrote a quote for the Boston Globe - spooky!).  And a disclaimer - this is tongue in cheek (I am after all a recovering regulator, and some of my best friends are bureaucrats)

Oh, by the way, some of the photos (top right) are from 2004 when we worked with Lithuanians to establish a CRT recycling operation with a scrap smelter and Ekranos (one of the east block CRT molding plants).  That year we were testing the monitors for resale, and I thought "tested working" was the answer.  I visited the SKD plant after one of these shipments and found they were throwing out the Suns, Trinitrons, and other "tested working" models.  All that's worthy of its own post.

Here's a more appropriate song... I shouldn't have to worry about offending anyone with this.  And this is played over actual footage of Good Point Recycling staff really moving PCs and color Teeeveeeeees.