The Anti-Reuse Excuse

During a tour at Good Point Recycling last week, someone posed the old question about "export for reuse", that eventually the items we sell to poorer countries won't work, and that at that point they will have a waste problem.   Are developing nations shifting another "eventual" environmental costs (like mining, refining, and manufacturing) to poor nations when we export for legitimate reuse?

We covered this in 2002.  The issues against reuse are Toxics Along for the Ride (items they don't want mixed in - BAN considers parts that may be removed to be TAR even if recycled), and items so old that they are obsolete (including "tested working").   No reputable environmental organization is calling for a ban on export of 6 year old working electronics, they are just concerned when it's not reused, when it's a loophole for end-of-life ewaste.  So, BAN is pro-Reuse, and has asked us to stop implying otherwise.

But for whoever planted that question on the tour (the lady said it was a criticism from a competitor), let's accept the postulate that the eventual disposal of a reused PC is a "CON".

The PRO's for export for reuse are pretty well settled.
  • Carbon production is mostly in the manufacture of new electronics.  So if the faster they are replaced with new items, the more carbon is produced.
  • Pollution from primary or virgin production is much higher than pollution from disposal.
  • The internet is growing at 10x the rate in countries earning $3k per year per capita GDP.  The difference in cost between a CRT which lasts 10 years and an LCD that lasts 4 years is huge when you earn $3k per year.
  • Breaking a CRT to remelt it glass-to-glass is also producing a CRT which will eventually be sold in a developing nation (they are still made in the millions per month, but not sold in rich nations), so breaking the CRT does not avoid the "Con".  New items also become obsolete.   
  • Fair trade programs, which require reuse/repair operations overseas to also recycle incidental breakage and take back "clunkers" when selling PCs locally, address the "eventual disposal" infrastructure (and boycotts do not).
  • CRTs are better for certain consumers than LCDs.  They are less prone to theft, endure non-air-conditioned environments, and last longer (20 years) than LCDs, and have better display qualities and refresh rates for certain applications.
  • Refusing to sell a reuse computer to someone who cannot hope to afford a new computer sentences the buyer to remain "backward, barefoot and pregnant" in the next decade.
When the CRT glass market for the CRTs we break finally goes away, and mankind stops making new CRTs which last 20 years, it may come the time to stop reusing working CRTs (good for ten years).  But if the affordable display market is going have 10 more years, not 20, then reused CRTs are better than new ones.   This is why Basel Action Network and WR3A are united on improving the reuse market, not just destroying working equipment.  

By the way, over 80% of the CRTs we randomly test today are working when collected from the generator;  most of the damage is in shipping and collection.  Working stats are even higher for units less than 10 years old.  Americans are getting rid of them because we can afford new new new LCDs, plasmas, and other flat screens.  Throwing away our leftovers in the face of a hungry market is stupid, expensive, gives the market to scumbags, and is just generally indefensible in any possible way.   The "e-waste" companies which are too lazy to test, to stupid to speak foreign languages, too disorganized to track purchase orders and sales, should not be badmouthing reuse organizations which use Fair Trade standards to create win-win scenarios, reducing carbon, reducing pollution, reducing costs, and creating internet access in poor countries.

Have I made my position clear?

Past Shock: Today E-Waste Event in Rutland Vermont

Today our company is holding a free collection event for used electronics in at the Rutland County Solid Waste District, from 9-1, at 2 Green Hill Road.   We are sorting electronics by brand, introducing a new coupon program (adding Panasonic, Sharp, Toshiba and Vizio), and training new staff (we don't have too many of these events this close to home in Vermont - Events are kinda 2004.  We'll be playing Brittany Spears - Toxic!).

It will be interesting to see how "events" play 9 months from now, when all e-waste collections are free in Vermont, and you don't avoid a $10 drop off fee by waiting in line.  Will people still come out in the rain to demonstrate their Earth Day credentials?  Or will ewaste recycling become, as it should be, like laundromats and tire replacement?

"Grandpa, we've heard that story."

The secret is that for most people, used electronics recycling is as boring as a car inspection.  We can thank the newness of the field, and the blizzard of "aha gotcha!" journalism stories.  The truth is that the action is in the Indonesia coral islands (being mined for tin to replace lead solder), the Congo jungles (where coltan is mined for cell phones), and the mountains of the Afghan Pakistan border, where used cell phones are being purchased and jerry-rigged.

We tried to spice up the old recycling stories (newspaper recycling, office paper recycling, bottle and can recycling) with "ju-ju" topics, like "toxicity of landfills" and "toxic ash from incinerators".   Some recyclers are trying to do the same thing with electronics, and have a lot of people convinced that a TV is toxic and poisonous in your basement (it's far more dangerous when plugged in and working in your living room).

Mass production of grey market, contract management, repair manuals, etc. is BORING.  The rapid obsolescence of brand new products has blurred the area between new and aftermarket.  Designing laws based on selling shoes in wholesale bulk that are "used" or shoes in wholesale bulk that are "new" is going to be a real head scratcher to the grandkids.  Not just that Grandpa talks about when recycling or laundromats or gas stations were "new and controversial", but that people actually tried passing laws to so tightle command, control, and influence the used stereo, laundromat, recycling, RAM upgrade, muffler patching businesses.

Good Points Well Taken - By China

A day after I wrote another absurdly academic post, directed at Allen Hershkowitz of NRDC, the morning news made my point.

I questioned yesterday how drastically "poisonous" the interpretation of Basel Annex IX (allowing export for repair) could be, when everyone agrees that China can:

1) Mine the rare earths and leads for the monitors
2) Refine and smelt the rare metals for the computers
3) Melt and mold the (virgin/new) CRTs and circuit boards
4) Take back product they sold for "repair under warranty"
5) Take back their own domestic e-waste (which dwarfs USA imports)

Somehow if the identical Chinese factory takes back a monitor NOT under warranty, they are going to be a toxic witches brew child poisoning disaster area. I'm talking about well screened computers, ones shipped to an ISO14001 audited facility, not blind shipments without TAR removed.    It seems like the Fair Trade Recycling solution has not been embraced by ewaste advocates because healing the wound is a threat to their sale of medicine.

Actually, its absurd that China cannot be relied on to recycle, let alone repair monitors.  But China has banned used goods imports, so we cannot go there under R2 for that reason anyway.  But this campaign to get India, Indonesia, Egypt, Kenya, Pakistan, etc. to also ban used goods imports is sick and environmentally hideous and wrong, wrong, wrong.

So anyway, today several news sources announced that Chinese engineers have made the worlds fastest supercomputer, 40% faster than the USA's largest.

If they repair or recycle it one day, it's not going to be the worst thing that has happened to China.   Let's can the denigration, innuendo, photographic sleight of hand, etc. which is being used to convince mainstream America that Shenzhen is a polluted rice paddy.  China has huge pollution problems.  Recycling is a SOLUTION, not a problem.

Two Party Intentions: NRDC and E-Waste

Allen Hershkowitz of Natural Resources Defense Council writes:
"While there are undoubtedly some ethical actors, what far more exporters are really doing is hiding behind phantom policies that sound nice but in fact export poisons to some of the poorest people on earth..."
His NRDC solution:
"Only properly tested, working equipment may be sold into developing countries.  No broken equipment should be exported."
Allen writes this months after his organization unfairly labeled a progressive contract manufacturing takeback company in Indonesia as "primitive", and weeks after a constructive meeting between WR3A and BAN to pursue use of the "export for repair" capacity (BAN insists certain non-working parts be removed from some units prior to repair, but allows export for repair if the part is not replaced.  WR3A on the other hand would allow the replaced parts to be properly recycled).

The NRDC's post harkens back to the "Foxconn is Guiyu" balderdash from last winter.  Apparently, Asian factories can make new monitors, and can take back working monitors, can mine and mold new CRTs, can take back and recycle non-working monitors generated within their own country, but if they take back their own non-working product sold in the USA, it is criminally polluting, poisonous and primitive?  

The NRDC is a reputable organization.   There is some possibility to interpret Allen's post as allowing properly documented repair and reuse, something that WR3A not only allows, but actively promotes.   WR3A's documentation on actual reuse, and proper recycling in incidental breakage, is something even E-Stewards "tested working" exporters may not have.  But we are discouraged from pursuing these compromises with NRDC if they continue to promote a simplistic solution to a naive diagnosis.

Here are some short but important points:
  1. The Basel Convention says export for repair and refurbishment of used electronics is legal.
  2. The Basel Convention says that used electronics might not even be considered "waste" by the Basel Parties.  It defers the "waste and commodity" determination to dual party agreements.
  3. Warranty repairs, OEM refurbishment, and other obviously legal activity could be disallowed under Allen's description.
  4. Fair Trade programs develop proper recycling infrastructure in the developing nations - where most of the e-waste disposed is actually from their own domestic generation, not from imports.
Due Disclosure.  NRDC raises the question of motives and conflicted interests.  Am I too much of an interested party to challenge NRDC on this front?   Most of the remaining exporters have taken cover underground, and some who want to stand beside me I really don't vouch for.  It's a fair question.

I have properly disclosed my company's exports of intact units - 22%.  Some of those exports were tested working.  Most have a hard drive removed before we get them, and we cannot find enough hard drives for all of them.  All have been screened to remove unrepairable units.  We get a reconciliation report, and can tell our clients exactly how many were refurbished, and how many were properly recycled (about 10%) in the export country, and provide proof the recycled portion is something to be proud of, not just comfortable with.  BAN has insinuated that our 10% recycling rate is too high, but has not provided "tested working" reconciliations to compare them to.

The remainder of the e-waste (the other 78%) my company must de-manufacture and recycle in the USA.  Interestingly, most of that 78% is technically working, but does not meet the specifications of the buyer.  We could embrace the "working" standard, exporting more product (BAN has posted a NYTimes article quoting a Pledge company which says they export 60%, not 22%).  In fair trade, plugging in items the buyers don't want doesn't work, even if the device does.   What exasperates me is that our higher standard, worked out jointly in a fair trade agreement, is being ignored at best, and at worst impugned as a lower standard than "e-Stewards" who shred and destroy working units, passing the costs on to consumers.

The value of a unit can be a potential bad influence or bad motivation for sale.  But the value of a unit is also a better predictor of its destiny overseas than "test working".  If the market offers you more for a Pentium 4 laptop without a keyboard than for a "fully functional" Pentium 3, it's not because the Pentium 4 will be set ablaze (Pentium 3s actually have more gold and copper).  This does not excuse people who use their good product to force movement of unscreened or junk product.  But it shows that the secondary electronics economy is a little more complex than the abridged "Basel Convention for dummies".  The Basel Convention Parties discussed export for repair, and explicitly made it conditionally legal under Annex IX, section B1110.

Refurbished and Repaired PCs
  So if I disclose I resell some products overseas, and I express frustration with NRDC, is it out of conflicted motives?  I have also gone to great lengths to demonstrate that my philosophy about refurbishing jobs in the developing world brought me into the used electronics field, not visa-versa.

Allen and other environmentalists who impugn electronics export markets fail to appreciate the beauty of dual party intent.  They have not visited the Big Secret Factories, describing export demand with poster children taken at dumps, attacking the best and the brightest techs in the developing nations with innuendo.  They probably really believe that more than 50% of exports are junk, but haven't researched or obtained data.  Without data or contact with overseas markets, they repeatedly come back to the motives of a single party.  I do appreciate evaluation of motives and conflicts of interest... it contributes to my understanding.  A little horse-sense also goes a long way.

  • A well meaning party can export working product which turns out to be waste.
  • A bad intentioned party can export untested product which is mostly repaired and reused.
  • A well meaning party can destroy non-working product which is actually better (once repaired) than the working product they are exporting.

Are the intentions and profit motives of the shipping party a good indicator of what is going to happen to your donated or recycled computer?  If the intentions are all you have to go by, it's probably better to use a company with good intentions. (On that note, if someone is on the payroll of a large e-Waste recycler in the NY/CT area, and that company has selected the e-Stewards over the EPA R2 standard, one needs to disclose this right up front).  But if there is more than just "motives" to measure, if there is data from dual party purchase orders, reconciliations, and post-audits available, why not engage them?

Perhaps because of the "profits" at stake from E-Stewards?  Why else ignore calls for, and offers of, numerators and denominators?

For NRDC to really move forward, the organization needs to engage and learn with those Allen calls "undoubtably ethical" actors.  If you find a combination of a two-party transaction which is not just "free trade" but also "fair trade", you will always do better than either blindly exporting working product or blindly exporting non-working product.   

It would be far wiser for the E-Stewards to export more, better, tested product, at lower prices, than to install shredders as altars to shiny consciences.  If they do think that most exports are junk, then forcing the export market to get their good units from junk sellers isn't very productive. Try giving repairable stuff away, newer and better than the "profit motivated" exporters, and you'll have more effect using the free market to your advantage.

If you do promote and push E-Stewards to engage the export for repair market, you will get to know some really cool Geeks of Color.  Like the previous generation of the Neu family, who sold "scraps to Japs" and helped in the process to rebuild postwar Japan and to increase trade and working relationships between the USA and what would become the second largest world economy, NRDC needs to soberly look at the consequences of prohibition.   Interviewing non-exporters about the intentions of the export market is not sufficient.

Tears in Heaven:  By the way, when I'm occasionally called a for-profit exporter defending my capitalist business model, I generally ignore it.  My close friends know that Robin Ingenthron is one of the few people discussing the pictures of children in Africa, who has held a dead African child.  I carried the two year old boy by the legs, and lowered him into the dirt grave I helped his despondent father to dig.  We wrapped him bathed in sheets, without a coffin, and buried him.  I do not remember the boys name. I am not more important for having done this. I remember vividly trying to decide exactly how long to continue picking and digging when we hit hard pan clay, knowing we had not made it to two meters.

The boy's father, Monsieur Moussa, happened to be a teacher of "Technology" at CES Ngaoundal in Cameroon Africa.  His father owned a green Nissan pickup truck, which he did his own repairs on, and drove us a few kilometers out of the village to dig the grave and hold the ceremony.  I was 23, so the boy today would now have been 25.  Mr. Moussa's better, geekier students, would sometimes be reading their technology texts in my English class, preparing for a big exam, studying electric schematic diagrams.  I like to think some of them are now repairing cell phones in Paris.

I do understand crusades, and the grey area between sanctimony and singularity of mission, and holy motivation.   I have often pushed back against my Ozark religious relatives who believe that Jesus is the only way to heaven.  A two year old boy of a Muslim father is not going to hell, I know that.  Arguing with people who think they are better than other people because of something they believe, whether it is religion or intent or other sanctimony, is a distraction.  What we need is data.  You get the best data talking to professional techs of color overseas who import hundreds of thousands of used USA computers.

Legal Dual Party Intent: Ewaste Part III

When waste occurs in the used goods and recycling export trade, it is from the same causes as waste produced in "brand new" and "tested working" markets (described in "Legal Dual Party Intent" parts I and II).  The remedy for waste is 1) Intent, and 2) Communication, and 3) Cost internalization.  We call this "Fair Trade".

Fair Trade recognizes demand.   When you have very strong and very legitimate demand, it's best not to over-restrict trade, but to reward instead the "Best Available" practices and technologies. Profitable exchanges with "Techs of Color" will leverage the trade to achieve even better outcomes.

Fair Trade is not perfect trade.  The two parties must enter into an agreement which is transparently with intent to improve outcomes, but it's a business.  Exchange rates fluctuate, demand fizzles and soars, and longshoremen are known to handle goods roughly.   The world is better off when good people nevertheless attempt those contracts.  The World Bank, USAID, Peace Corps, and Kiva all know that there is risk to making loans, doing business, and getting your hands dirty.  But a surgeon who is afraid to pick up a scalpel may as well get out of the way.

A shiny conscience has as much value as an uncirculated coin... valuable to collectors only.

Whether the e-waste in the developing nation comes from brand new product which breaks down, new products returned to the (developing-nation) manufacturer under warranty, a material handler on a fast forklift, improperly inspected "tested working" products for exports, or lazy "toxics along for the ride", it's there.   Every one of these activities has the same result - a broken circuit board in a developing nation - it is foolish to say that each activity is equal. A result is not a verb, and is not necessarily a crime.  What we need is communication and dual party intent.

Environmentalists' challenge is to look at each activity closely, and determine if the importers and exporter are communicating correctly, and providing incentives to correct for cost externalization.  If neither party has the intent to pollute, then you can say that the "e-waste" was generated upon receipt, and must be dealt with properly.  It's unnecessary to say that an "e-waste" crime has been committed by the generator with good intentions, who is filling a need.

The biggest misconception in the "E-waste Industry" is the pretense that perfectly repaired-in-USA goods are available, and importers just cannot find them.  The USA doesn't fix things as well as Egypt or India or China does.  We invent new things.  Faced with a pile of working (but untested) computers, the "best available" practice is to allow Techs of Color to (at worst) repair them without resorting to underground smuggling.

When you enter this trade and record each transaction, patterns become clear when "transboundary" shipments of non-working product accumulate in non-OECD countries.  Failure to test the product is not high on the list.


1) Circumstances beyond control of the parties to the trade.

Acts of god and congress.   When a load of working computers is intercepted in Egypt, and customs officials seize the goods and dismantle them, waste occurs.  Storms, accidents in handling by longshoremen, etc. are other examples.

2)  Mistakes in planning, changes in markets

An importer may buy 10,000 televisions, working etc., which they have sold in the past, and find they can only sell 8,000 of them.  Diminishing returns on inventory happens in brand new product, resulting in "surplus property".  This is more likely to be discarded, but was never illegal or intended.  The same occurs when sellers of tested working equipment fail to understand that languages, hemispheric changes, voltage, and mistaken demand occurs in the tested working, fully functional markets.  Communication with the buyer is key.


3) Along for the Ride

When two parties agree strongly on 70% of a load, there is diminished concern over what "rides" on the last portion of a container.   If you have a large car trunk, you are more likely to bring more food on a camping trip, and will produce more waste at the campsite.  Same principle with a 40 cubic yard container of computer monitors... if you have spaces for 100 more monitors, you may be tempted to toss on monitors outside of the PO (Apple, Sun, 21", Trinitron which are "tested working" are common "TAR" items, not desired in secondary markets overseas).  This is the problem WR3A has focused on. 

Eliminating the good 70% is a tremendous blunder;  reducing the junk 30% is imperative.

In none of the cases above do you see "75%" or "80%" waste in the used electronics trade.  Those are simply not repeatable numbers. 

Rich nations must deal with "along for the ride" material without burying our heads in the sand, by grouping all Geeks of Color in the same "primitive" boat as children torching wires.  Dual Party Intent contracts have been created after visits to buyers, meetings with import officials, operation of a recycling company, years of regulatory experience, a degree in international relations, experience in the Peace Corps in developing countries, etc.

The best available practices and outcomes will be achieved if 1) more good and working equipment is preserved, rather than "cancelled", to give buyers more choice of supplies, 2) there is more communication (dual) with the purchasing market (don't drive them underground), and 3) good people are not afraid to deal with other good people.

As the Wall Street Journal's Alessandro Torello reports, the European Union has been unable to distinguish secondary (recycled) materials trade from trash disposal, and American e-waste advocates seem willing to emulate a bureaucracy which cannot distinguish between Beliden, Umicore, and waste management in Naples.  The perfect has become the enemy of the good.  In the case of computer reuse, the "perfect" has named the good as it's chief target.  Perfect, slow down on the friendly fire.  You have set up lofty goals which your followers are not even trying to meet.  Your stewards adapted "no intact unit" programs which renounce reuse income, ceding good markets to less scrupulous sellers.  In frustration, they are lashing out at those sellers, and impacting the Best Available Fair Trade markets.

Stop the digital bloodshed.  This clip from the 1976  Allegro Non Troppo, the "Italian Fantasia" movie by Bruno Bozetto, is a tribute to what can happen to a Coke bottle, and what extraction and consumption is on a path towards.